Disability happens. If you thought about it, you may have purchased a short-term or long-term disability policy, to help protect your income and your family’s lifestyle in the unfortunate and sometimes unlikely event that you become disabled during your work years. Now the unthinkable has happened. You have had an accident, or your doctor has told you that you should stop working, or you realize you cannot keep working due to a multitude of disabling medical conditions. Now is the time to file your Disability Application, but what are you entitled to?
If you have purchased a long-term disability policy, either through your employer’s benefits or a private insurance policy, then you may have different types of protection and you need to know the difference because one thing you should know is that insurance companies usually will deny these claims, fight your claims, or stop your payments at some point because that is what insurance companies do.
What Kind Of Disability Policy Do I Have And Why Does It Matter?
You may have purchased your disability policy through your employer. These policies are generally covered under Employee Benefits Laws, particularly the law known as Employee Retirement Security Income Act (ERSI), and there are significant limitations and issues related to these types of insurance policies. However, you may also have purchased a private disability insurance policy known as an individual or private (ID) disability policy. Either way, you have made a smart choice to have some type of income protection if you become disabled, but there are significant differences between these types of policies and you must understand what those differences are before you file a claim.
What Do You Need To Do Before You Stop Working?
Unless you have had a traumatic injury, you will oftentimes have time to consider that you may have to stop working and file for disability under your insurance policy. Unfortunately, there is no uniform or standard disability policy. Prior to stopping working or even applying for benefits, the first thing you should do is get a copy of your disability policy and read it cover to cover. While some of the words seem familiar and seem to make sense, there are many traps that you need to understand before you stop working. If you stop working on the wrong day, if you do not understand the limitations in your policy of the coverage, or how the other money you collect (i.e., Social Security, Workers’ Compensation or personal injury) could reduce your benefits, you could be in for a rude awakening.
What Medical Conditions Let Me Get Disability Insurance?
Your medical conditions, even if they are “disabling,” may not actually be covered by the policy that you have. Some policies limit the period of time that you can get coverage, (as short as two years), for mental nervous conditions. Some people have made applications where there are preexisting medical conditions that might be excluded, as a cause of disability. Conditions like migraines, diagnoses like fibromyalgia, and other uncommon types of conditions may also be excluded. It is essential that you understand any limitations on your coverage before you apply so that you can do so in the right way.
When Should I Apply?
While this seems to be a simple question, it is not. If you are unable to continue working or your physician has told you to stop working, then it is time to apply for benefits. However, you could actually pick the wrong date to stop working, which can completely sink your claim for benefits.
What Information Do I Need To File A Claim?
The disability claims process is all about paperwork, paperwork, paperwork. Even in this day of electronic records, it is all about the paper. This is supposedly designed to allow the disability insurance company to make the proper decision but is actually created to delay or even deny your claim. Making sure that you gather the correct information, that your doctors provide the right type of medical reports, and that you provide the right type of supporting documentation, such as the proper financial or economic data, will make the difference between what you get, and when you get it, and even if you get long-term disability benefits.
But I paid premiums, I do not understand why the insurance company would like to deny my case. This is a common statement I hear from applicants or people who have been denied. The bottom line is that disability insurance companies are a business and they are in the business of denying claims and making money based on the premiums that they collected from you for so many years. There are many loopholes and many dangers in these policies, and if you do not file in the proper way and follow the rules, you can make seemingly innocent but fatal mistakes in the application, which will completely undermine your ability to ever win your case.
How Does A Disability Carrier Decide My Case And How Long Will It Take?
The disability insurance companies have sophisticated systems to evaluate and decide a disability claim, and they use a playbook that tells their examiners decisions to make, and how to make them, which definitely lean toward denying your claim. The disability carriers will often play the ‘we need more information game’, which will delay your payments, and payments delayed are the equivalent of payments denied for many people who are suffering from wage loss as a result of disabilities.
Why Should You Have An Attorney Help Prepare Your Initial Application After All This Is Supposed TO be A Simple System
Many people who have long-term disability insurance policies or personal individual disability policies believe that the form, usually a few pages, is fairly simple and should be easily filled out, and therefore benefits awarded. However, as we have mentioned this is not as simple as it seems. In fact, we deal with many professionals such as doctors, lawyers, accountants, and others with advanced degrees who purchase private disability policies to protect their income and lifestyle, yet the disability insurance companies regularly dispute the policyholder’s application, occupation, pre-disability income, limitations on the ability to perform the material, and substantial duties of your occupation, residual disability, and many other factors. We often have discussions with potential clients who have filled out applications thinking it is simple and anyone can tell that they are disabled, yet they have done irreparable harm to their cases. That is why it is important from the start to make sure your application is filled out properly, supported, and literally undeniable.
Our main offices are located in:
- White Plains, Westchester County
- New York City
- Long Island
- Brooklyn
- Goshen, NY
- Yonkers / Bronx
- Newburgh
Frequently Asked Questions
Long term disability in New York covers a wide range of medical conditions that prevent you from working, including back injuries, cancer, heart disease, mental health disorders, arthritis, and neurological conditions. Each policy defines qualifying conditions differently, so reviewing your specific policy language is essential. Insurance companies evaluate whether your condition meets the policy's definition of disability, which typically requires medical documentation from your physician. The Disability Guys has helped thousands of New York residents understand which conditions their policies cover and how to properly document their claims. Common qualifying conditions require ongoing treatment and demonstrate that you cannot perform your job duties. Getting a long term disability lawyer involved early ensures your condition is properly documented and presented to the insurance company.
The approval timeline for long term disability in New York typically ranges from 30 to 90 days, though some cases take longer depending on the complexity of your medical condition and how quickly you submit required documentation. Insurance companies must review your application, medical records, and employment history before making a determination. Delays often occur when medical evidence is incomplete or when the insurer requests additional information. Working with a long term disability lawyer in New York can expedite this process by ensuring all documentation is thorough and properly submitted from the start. Many claimants experience unnecessary delays due to incomplete applications. Having professional guidance helps prevent common mistakes that slow down approval. Some cases may require appeals, which can extend the timeline significantly, making early legal consultation valuable.
Insurance companies in New York deny long term disability claims for several reasons: incomplete medical documentation, failure to meet the policy's definition of disability, gaps in treatment records, or alleged failure to follow prescribed treatment plans. Some denials occur because claimants don't properly explain how their condition prevents them from working. Insurance companies are profit-driven entities that often scrutinize claims carefully before approving benefits. The Disability Guys understands these denial tactics and has extensive experience challenging improper denials throughout New York. Common reasons include insufficient detail about your work limitations, missing medical records, or the insurer's interpretation that you can perform other job duties. Many denials are actually reversible with proper legal representation and additional evidence. Understanding why your claim was denied is the first step toward appealing successfully and securing the long term disability benefits you deserve in New York.
Yes, you can appeal a denied long term disability claim in New York, and you typically have a limited timeframe to do so—often 30 to 60 days depending on your policy. The appeal process requires submitting additional medical evidence, detailed explanations of your work limitations, and sometimes expert medical opinions to counter the insurer's denial. New York law provides specific procedures for appealing group disability claims under ERISA and individual policy denials. A long term disability lawyer in New York can significantly improve your appeal's success rate by presenting compelling evidence and legal arguments. The Disability Guys has successfully overturned numerous denials by gathering stronger medical documentation and challenging the insurance company's reasoning. Appeals require careful attention to deadlines and procedural requirements. Many claimants strengthen their appeals by obtaining updated medical evaluations that more clearly document their disability. Professional legal representation ensures your appeal meets all requirements and presents the strongest possible case.
Employer-sponsored long term disability policies in New York are governed by ERISA (Employee Retirement Income Security Act) and typically offer broader protections but come with specific procedural requirements and limitations. Private disability insurance policies are individual contracts between you and an insurance company, offering more flexibility but potentially stricter definitions of disability. ERISA claims have specific appeal rights and timelines, while private policy claims follow different state insurance regulations. Understanding which type of policy you have is crucial because the rules, appeal processes, and available remedies differ significantly. The Disability Guys helps New York residents navigate both types of policies and understand their specific rights and obligations. ERISA policies sometimes provide better long term disability lawyer protections under federal law, while private policies may offer clearer language about coverage. Each type requires different strategies when filing or appealing claims. Knowing your policy type determines which long term disability lawyer approach will be most effective in New York.
Long term disability lawyers in New York typically work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing upfront and only pay if you win your case. Contingency fees usually range from 20% to 33% of the benefits recovered, though this varies by attorney and case complexity. Some lawyers charge hourly rates ranging from $150 to $400 per hour, while others may charge flat fees for specific services. The Disability Guys offers transparent fee structures and discusses costs clearly before taking your case, ensuring you understand the financial arrangement. Many long term disability claims in New York involve substantial benefit amounts, making contingency representation affordable and accessible. You should never pay upfront fees to pursue long term disability benefits. Always ask about fee arrangements during your initial consultation with any long term disability lawyer. Understanding the cost structure helps you make an informed decision about legal representation for your New York disability claim.
Filing a long term disability claim in New York requires comprehensive documentation including your original policy, medical records from all treating physicians, diagnostic test results, treatment plans, and a detailed description of how your condition prevents you from working. You'll need employment records showing your job duties and income, proof of any work attempts, and statements from your doctors confirming your disability. Insurance companies scrutinize every document, so completeness and accuracy are essential. The Disability Guys recommends organizing all medical records chronologically and obtaining a detailed letter from your primary physician explaining your specific work limitations. Missing or incomplete documentation is a leading cause of long term disability denials in New York. Your long term disability lawyer can help identify which documents strengthen your claim and which gaps need filling. Gathering thorough documentation before filing prevents delays and reduces the likelihood of denial or requests for additional information from the insurance company.
If your long term disability benefits stop in New York, the insurance company must provide written notice explaining the reason, which might include: recovery from your condition, failure to provide updated medical records, or policy termination. You have the right to appeal the termination and request reconsideration if you believe the decision is incorrect. Many benefit terminations occur prematurely when insurance companies claim improvement without sufficient medical evidence. A long term disability lawyer in New York can review the termination notice and determine whether grounds exist for appeal or legal action. The Disability Guys has helped numerous New York residents restore benefits that were wrongfully terminated. If you disagree with the termination, you must act quickly—appeal deadlines are strict. Gathering current medical evidence showing your ongoing disability is crucial for successful reinstatement. Understanding your rights when benefits stop is essential to protecting your income and livelihood in New York.
You should consider hiring a long term disability lawyer in New York if your claim has been denied, if the insurance company requests extensive additional information, if your benefits have been terminated, or if you're unsure about your policy coverage. Complex medical conditions, self-employed status, or significant benefit amounts also warrant professional legal guidance. Many claimants successfully navigate initial approvals without legal help, but representation becomes valuable when disputes arise. The Disability Guys recommends consulting with a long term disability lawyer early in the process to avoid costly mistakes. Having a lawyer review your claim before submission can prevent denials and appeals. If you're facing communication difficulties with the insurance company or feel pressured to accept an unfavorable decision, professional representation protects your interests. A long term disability lawyer in New York can evaluate your specific situation and advise whether legal representation will benefit your claim and maximize your benefits.
Whether you can work part-time while receiving long term disability benefits in New York depends entirely on your specific policy language and the insurance company's definition of disability. Some policies allow limited work activity below a certain income threshold, while others prohibit any work. Your policy may include a "residual" or "partial" disability provision that permits reduced work capacity. You must disclose any work activity to your insurance company, as failing to report income can result in benefit termination or legal consequences. The Disability Guys advises reviewing your policy carefully and consulting with your long term disability lawyer before attempting any work while on benefits. Insurance companies monitor earnings closely and may reduce or eliminate benefits if you exceed policy limits. Some policies allow you to test your ability to work without penalty during a trial period. Understanding your specific policy's work provisions prevents accidental violations. Your long term disability lawyer in New York can clarify your policy's rules and help you navigate work activity without jeopardizing your benefits.
The definition of disability under long term disability insurance in New York varies by policy but typically requires that you cannot perform the material duties of your own occupation due to injury or illness. Some policies use an "any occupation" definition, which is more restrictive and requires that you cannot perform any job you're reasonably qualified for. Early in your benefit period, most policies use the "own occupation" definition, which is more favorable to claimants. After a certain period, policies may switch to an "any occupation" standard, making continued benefits harder to obtain. Understanding your specific policy's definition is crucial for long term disability claims in New York. The Disability Guys helps claimants understand how their policy defines disability and whether their condition meets that definition. Medical evidence must clearly demonstrate that you cannot perform your job duties, not simply that you're experiencing symptoms. Your long term disability lawyer in New York can analyze your policy language and build a case showing you meet the applicable disability definition.
The duration of long term disability benefits in New York depends on your specific policy, which might provide benefits until age 65, for a fixed number of years (such as two or five years), or until your condition improves. Some policies offer lifetime benefits for disabilities occurring before a certain age. Your policy documents outline the exact benefit period and any conditions that might end coverage earlier. Understanding your benefit duration helps you plan financially and understand when coverage might terminate. The Disability Guys reviews policy language to clarify benefit duration and help claimants understand their long term financial protection. Some policies include provisions allowing extension of benefits beyond the standard period under certain circumstances. You should review your policy documents carefully or consult a long term disability lawyer in New York to understand exactly how long your benefits will continue. Knowing your benefit period helps you prepare for potential termination and understand your long term financial security.
Immediately after becoming disabled in New York, seek medical treatment and obtain detailed documentation from your healthcare providers about your condition and work limitations. Notify your employer and request information about your long term disability insurance coverage and the claims process. Gather your policy documents and review coverage details, benefit amounts, and filing deadlines. Begin collecting medical records, diagnostic results, and treatment plans that support your disability claim. Document how your condition prevents you from performing your job duties with specific examples. The Disability Guys recommends consulting with a long term disability lawyer early to avoid procedural mistakes that could jeopardize your claim. File your claim promptly to avoid missing deadlines that could result in denial. Keep detailed records of all communications with your employer and insurance company. Avoid social media posts that might contradict your disability claim. Taking these immediate steps positions you for successful long term disability benefits in New York and protects your rights throughout the claims process.
No, your employer cannot legally retaliate against you for filing a long term disability claim in New York. Federal ERISA law and New York state employment laws protect employees from retaliation, including termination, demotion, or reduced benefits for asserting disability rights. Retaliation includes any adverse employment action taken because you filed a claim or pursued benefits. If you experience retaliation after filing a long term disability claim in New York, you may have legal remedies available. A long term disability lawyer in New York can help you document retaliation and pursue appropriate legal action against your employer. The Disability Guys has represented claimants who faced employer retaliation and successfully protected their rights. Examples of retaliation include termination shortly after filing, negative performance reviews unrelated to work performance, or denial of promotions. You should report any suspicious employment actions to your long term disability lawyer immediately. Understanding your legal protections against retaliation empowers you to pursue long term disability benefits without fear of employer punishment in New York.
The appeals process for long term disability claims in New York typically involves submitting additional evidence, a detailed written response to the denial reasons, and sometimes a request for external review. You must meet strict deadlines—usually 30 to 60 days from the denial notice—to preserve your appeal rights. Your appeal should directly address each reason the insurance company cited for denial and provide stronger medical evidence supporting your disability. ERISA claims in New York have specific procedural requirements, including the right to review the insurance company's file and submit comments. The Disability Guys guides claimants through each appeal step, ensuring compliance with all procedural requirements and deadlines. Many successful appeals include updated medical evaluations, vocational expert opinions, or additional documentation the initial claim lacked. Your long term disability lawyer in New York can identify weaknesses in the insurance company's reasoning and build a compelling rebuttal. Understanding the appeals process and acting quickly significantly improves your chances of overturning a denial and securing long term disability benefits.
Social Security Disability Insurance (SSDI) and long term disability insurance are separate programs with different eligibility requirements, benefit amounts, and application processes in New York. SSDI is a federal program based on your work history and contributions, while long term disability insurance is typically employer-sponsored or privately purchased coverage. You can potentially receive both SSDI and long term disability benefits simultaneously, though some policies include offsets reducing benefits if you receive SSDI. Understanding the relationship between these programs is crucial for maximizing your total disability income in New York. Many claimants benefit from pursuing both SSDI and long term disability claims concurrently. The Disability Guys helps New York residents navigate both programs and understand how they interact. Long term disability claims often move faster than SSDI applications, providing immediate income while SSDI is pending. Your long term disability lawyer in New York can coordinate your claims to ensure you receive all available benefits. Consulting with a professional helps you understand how these programs work together to support your financial security.
If your insurance company requests an independent medical examination (IME) for your long term disability claim in New York, you have the right to attend and bring your own physician or representative. The IME is conducted by a doctor selected by the insurance company, which creates potential bias toward the insurer's interests. You should prepare thoroughly by bringing your medical records, documenting your symptoms and limitations, and being honest about your condition. The insurance company will use the IME report to evaluate your claim, so the examination is critical to your long term disability case in New York. The Disability Guys recommends having your long term disability lawyer review the IME report and challenge any findings that contradict your medical evidence. If the IME contradicts your treating physicians' opinions, your lawyer can obtain a rebuttal evaluation from your doctor. Many claimants successfully challenge unfavorable IME findings with proper legal representation. Understanding your rights during the IME process and preparing adequately protects your interests and strengthens your long term disability claim in New York.
Handling long term disability claims while self-employed in New York presents unique challenges because you must prove both that you purchased coverage and that your condition prevents you from earning income from your business. Self-employed individuals typically purchase individual disability policies rather than employer-sponsored plans, requiring careful policy review and documentation. You'll need detailed financial records showing your income before disability and evidence that you cannot perform your business duties. Insurance companies scrutinize self-employed claims more carefully, requiring comprehensive medical documentation and sometimes vocational expert opinions. A long term disability lawyer in New York can help self-employed individuals navigate these complex claims and present strong evidence of disability. The Disability Guys has represented numerous self-employed New York residents in disability claims, understanding the specific documentation requirements. Self-employed claimants must demonstrate they cannot perform any aspect of their business, not just their primary duties. Having professional legal representation significantly improves approval rates for self-employed long term disability claims in New York.
Your long term disability benefits generally continue if you move out of New York, as long as your policy remains in effect and you continue meeting the disability definition. However, you must notify your insurance company of your address change and any changes to your medical care or employment status. Some policies include provisions specific to New York law, and moving may affect how those provisions apply. Your long term disability lawyer in New York can advise whether relocation impacts your specific policy coverage or benefits. The Disability Guys recommends maintaining clear communication with your insurance company about any life changes, including relocation. Moving doesn't automatically terminate benefits, but failure to notify the insurer could cause problems if they later discover undisclosed information. You should continue providing required medical documentation and updates regardless of your location. Understanding how relocation affects your long term disability benefits helps you maintain coverage while moving. Consulting with your long term disability lawyer before relocating ensures you take appropriate steps to protect your ongoing benefits.
Yes, you can receive long term disability benefits for mental health conditions in New York, including depression, anxiety, bipolar disorder, and PTSD, provided your policy covers mental health disabilities and your condition meets the policy's definition of disability. Mental health claims require strong medical documentation from psychiatrists or psychologists showing your condition prevents you from working. Insurance companies sometimes scrutinize mental health claims more carefully than physical conditions, requiring detailed treatment records and evidence of ongoing therapy or medication. Your mental health condition must significantly impair your ability to perform your job duties to qualify for long term disability benefits in New York. A long term disability lawyer in New York can help you present mental health evidence effectively and counter any bias the insurance company might have. The Disability Guys has successfully represented claimants with mental health disabilities, understanding the documentation requirements and common denial reasons. Many mental health claims are initially denied but successfully appealed with proper legal representation and additional evidence. Your long term disability lawyer can ensure your mental health condition receives fair consideration in your New York disability claim.