How is pain and suffering calculated in a New York Personal Injury case?
What you need to know
Pain and suffering is often the largest component of a Personal Injury award, yet it has no receipt or pay stub attached to it. New York juries are instructed to award a fair and reasonable sum based on the evidence presented.
Factors That Drive Pain and Suffering Awards
- Severity and permanence of the injury — a permanent spinal cord injury commands far more than a soft-tissue strain that fully healed
- Age of the injured person — a 30-year-old with a permanent disability has more future years of suffering than a 70-year-old
- Impact on daily life — inability to work, care for children, pursue hobbies, or maintain relationships
- Credibility of the testimony — how clearly and honestly you describe your pain to the jury matters enormously
- Medical documentation — consistent treatment records, MRIs showing objective findings, and physician narratives support higher awards
The Serious Injury Requirement
In car accident cases, you cannot recover pain and suffering at all unless you clear the serious injury threshold under Insurance Law §5102(d). This includes fractures, permanent limitation, significant disfigurement, and the 90/180-day disability rule.
Appellate Review
New York courts can reduce a pain and suffering verdict if it deviates materially from what would be reasonable compensation — the standard set by CPLR §5501(c). Defense attorneys will ask the court to cut large verdicts. Your attorney will argue against any reduction.
New York's pure comparative negligence rule under CPLR §1411 reduces your award by your share of fault. File within three years under CPLR 214. No fee unless we win.
Other ways we help
Same firm, same approach — different practice areas under one roof.
Workers’ Compensation
Injured at work. Lost wages. Denied benefits.
Learn more →Social Security Disability
Can’t work due to a disability. SSDI & SSI claims, denials, appeals.
Learn more →Long-Term Disability
Private LTD insurance denied or cut off. ERISA appeals.
Learn more →Personal Injury
Car accident. Construction site. Scaffold Law.
Learn more →Workers’ Rights
Retaliation, wage theft, harassment. Plaintiff-side only.
Learn more →The attorneys who work your case
Not a call centre. The lawyer who signs you is the lawyer who shows up.
Brian M. Mittman, Esq.
Managing Partner · Markhoff & Mittman, P.C.
Call 866-205-2415 Schedule with Brian- Admitted in New York
- 30+ years in practice
- Attends Board hearings personally
Brian has personally handled New York workers' compensation, SSDI, and personal-injury cases for over three decades. Your case is never handed off to a paralegal.
- Admitted in New York and New Jersey
- Pace University School of Law, J.D.
- Litigates before the Workers' Compensation Board
Randy has litigated every type of claim before the Workers' Compensation Board on behalf of hundreds of claimants.
- Admitted in New York, 2008
- New York Law School, J.D. 2007
- With The Disability Guys since 2013
Benai has spent more than a decade fighting for injured workers before the Workers' Compensation Board and the New York State Employees' Retirement Board.
- Admitted in New York, 2007
- 20 years in practice
- Fluent in Spanish
Emily has spent two decades on New York workers' compensation and Social Security Disability matters, including service as an Agency Attorney and Hearing Officer for NYC Transit and the MTA.
- Admitted in New York, 2023
- Albany Law School, J.D. 2022
- Handles Third Department appeals
Lauren represents injured workers in Workers' Compensation matters and handles appeals before the Appellate Division, Third Department.
Talk to a real attorney today.
Free consultation. No fee unless we win. English or Spanish. Day or night.