# ERISA Federal Court | NY Long-Term Disability

Skip to main content    [![The Disability Guys logo](https://thedisabilityguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/the-disability-guys-logo-horizontal.png)](/)   [Chat](https://intaker.com/markhoffmittmanpc/disabilityguys) [Text](sms:19145065665) [Call](tel:18662052415)  [EN](/long-term-disability/erisa-federal-court/)/[ES](/es/long-term-disability/erisa-federal-court/)    Who We Are[About The Disability Guys](/why-tdg/)[Our Results](/why-tdg/#reviews-headline)[Our Team](/our-team/)[Our Locations](/locations/)What We Do[Workers’ Compensation](/workers-compensation/)[SSDI](/social-security-disability/)[Disability](/long-term-disability/)[Personal Injury](/personal-injury-lawyers-in-new-york/)How We Work[Our Process](/#steps-headline)[What You Can Expect](/contact-us/)[Insights & Resource Library](/insights/)[Referral Partners](/for-partners/)[Call 866-205-2415](tel:18662052415)[Chat](https://intaker.com/markhoffmittmanpc/disabilityguys)[Text](sms:19145065665)             Long-Term Disability FAQs

# When the Administrative Process Fails, Federal Court Is the Next Step.

Quick Answer ERISA litigation in the S.D.N.Y. and E.D.N.Y. is a specialized area of federal practice. The rules are narrow, the record is fixed, and the standard of review often favors the insurer. You need counsel who knows this terrain.    [Call 866-205-2415](tel:18662052415)   Available 24/7  Hablamos Español  Free consultation          ![A client and two members of the legal team working through a case file at a desk](https://thedisabilityguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/tdg-intake-team-office.jpg)   About ERISA Federal Court

## ERISA Litigation Is Unlike Any Other Disability Case

When an employer-sponsored LTD claim is denied and the administrative appeal is exhausted, the claim moves to federal court under 29 U.S.C. §1132(a)(1)(B). There is no jury. There is generally no discovery beyond the administrative record. The case is decided on cross-motions for summary judgment — paper submissions reviewed by a federal judge. The standard of review is the most consequential variable. Under Firestone Tire and Rubber Co. v. Bruch, 489 U.S. 101 (1989), if the plan grants the insurer discretionary authority, the court reviews the decision for abuse of discretion rather than de novo. That is a hard standard to beat — which is why building an airtight administrative record during the appeal is the predicate for every successful federal case.

Key Topics

## What you need to know

Plain-English answers to the questions that come up most often on these cases.

[### De Novo vs. Abuse-of-Discretion Review De novo review — where the court decides the issue fresh — applies when the plan does not grant the insurer clear discretionary authority. Abuse-of-discretion review applies when it does. Most employer-sponsored group plans include discretionary authority clauses. The Second Circuit applies Firestone and its progeny carefully — but the baseline remains deferential to the plan administrator. Read more→](/long-term-disability/)[### The Closed Administrative Record In most ERISA cases, the federal court reviews only the evidence that was before the plan administrator during the administrative process. New expert reports, new medical records, and new arguments generally cannot be introduced in federal court. This is why the appeal must be treated as the trial — not as a preliminary step. Read more→](/long-term-disability/)[### Cross-Motions for Summary Judgment ERISA LTD cases are typically resolved on cross-motions for summary judgment. Both sides submit briefs and supporting documents from the administrative record. The judge decides as a matter of law — reviewing the insurer’s decision against the record evidence and the applicable standard of review. Read more→](/long-term-disability/)[### Conflict of Interest Under Glenn When the insurer both funds benefits and decides claims, Metropolitan Life Ins. Co. v. Glenn, 554 U.S. 105 (2008) requires the conflict to be weighed as one factor in the abuse-of-discretion analysis. Documenting the structural conflict — through claim file analysis, IME history, and internal communications obtained during litigation — remains an important litigation tool. Read more→](/long-term-disability/)[### Statute of Limitations ERISA does not specify a statute of limitations for benefit claims. Courts apply the most analogous state law limitations period, but many plan documents contain contractual limitations clauses that shorten the window — sometimes to as little as one year after the final denial. Missing that deadline bars the claim entirely. Read more→](/long-term-disability/)[### Attorney Fees Under ERISA 29 U.S.C. §1132(g) permits courts to award reasonable attorney fees and costs to either party. Prevailing claimants often recover fees — a meaningful consideration in case valuation and settlement negotiations. Read more→](/long-term-disability/)        How We Handle It

## How we handle these cases

1

### Step 1

Analyze the plan document for the standard of review before accepting any federal court case.

2

### File the complaint within the plan’s contractual limitations period

never the state limitations period alone.

3

### Step 3

Submit a comprehensive summary judgment brief that highlights every failure in the insurer’s administrative process.

4

### Step 4

Argue Glenn conflicts of interest using documented patterns of biased IME selection and file-review practices.

5

### Step 5

Evaluate settlement throughout the litigation with an accurate assessment of attorney fee recovery.

Case Results

## Real cases. Real results.

Three recent Long-Term Disability outcomes — case context and result. No client identifying information.

ERISA Federal Court Summary Judgment Won in S.D.N.Y.

After an insurer denied benefits to a technology executive with a debilitating autoimmune condition, we litigated in the Southern District of New York. The court found the insurer’s reliance on a paper-review physician — over years of treating specialist documentation — to be an abuse of discretion. Benefits were reinstated with prejudgment interest.

ERISA Federal Court Pre-Litigation Settlement After Federal Filing

Filing in federal court prompted a rapid settlement in a case involving a benefits termination at the 24-month transition. The insurer agreed to a lump-sum settlement that included past benefits, future benefits through maximum benefit age, and attorneys fees.

ERISA Federal Court De Novo Review Secured — and Won

We successfully argued that the plan document did not contain a valid discretionary authority clause. The court applied de novo review and found in our client’s favor, awarding benefits and fees under 29 U.S.C. §1132(g).

Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Each case is evaluated on its own facts. The case outcomes shown are representative examples; details have been altered or generalized to protect client confidentiality.

Related Questions

## Related questions

Quick answers from our FAQ library.

[What is the ERISA federal court process?](/long-term-disability/faq-erisa-federal-court-process/)[What is ERISA and how does it affect my LTD claim?](/long-term-disability/faq-what-is-erisa/)[Should I settle my LTD claim or go to litigation?](/long-term-disability/faq-settlement-vs-litigation-ltd/)[What is the 180-day appeal deadline under ERISA?](/long-term-disability/faq-180-day-appeal-deadline/)         Reviewed by Brian M. Mittman, Esq. Managing Partner · Markhoff & Mittman, P.C. · Admitted in New York

Brian Mittman has personally handled New York Workers’ Compensation, SSDI, LTD, and Personal Injury cases for over three decades.

Last reviewed: May 14, 2026        Related Practice Areas

## Other ways we help

Same firm, same approach — different practice areas under one roof.

[### Workers’ Compensation Injured at work. Lost wages. Denied benefits. Learn more →](/workers-compensation/)[### Social Security Disability Can’t work due to a disability. SSDI & SSI claims, denials, appeals. Learn more →](/social-security-disability/)[### Personal Injury Car accident. Construction site. Scaffold Law. Learn more →](/personal-injury-lawyers-in-new-york/)[### Workers’ Rights Retaliation, wage theft, harassment. Plaintiff-side only. Learn more →](/workers-rights/)       7 Offices Across New York

## Long-Term Disability lawyers near you

Seven New York offices serving working clients across the state.

[White Plains120 Bloomingdale Road, Suite 403, White Plains, NY 10605Call (914) 946-1452](/locations/white-plains/)[Yonkers51 Smart Avenue, Suite 200A, Yonkers, NY 10704Call (914) 600-3874](/locations/yonkers/)[Manhattan1825 Park Avenue, Suite 901, New York, NY 10035Call (212) 897-9004](/locations/manhattan/)[Brooklyn300 Cadman Plaza West, 12th Floor, Room 12071, Brooklyn, NY 11201Call (718) 509-3599](/locations/brooklyn/)[Newburgh320 Robinson Avenue, Suite 217, Newburgh, NY 12550Call (845) 299-8095](/locations/newburgh/)[Goshen3 Hatfield Lane, Suite 2D, Goshen, NY 10924Call (845) 360-9931](/locations/goshen/)[Poughkeepsie42 Catherine Street, Suite A, Poughkeepsie, NY 12601Call (845) 935-0017](/locations/poughkeepsie/)        Your Legal Team

## The attorneys who work your case

Not a call center. The lawyer who signs you is the lawyer who shows up.

- ![Brian M. Mittman, Esq.](https://thedisabilityguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/tdg-brian-mittman.jpg) ## Brian M. Mittman, Esq. Managing Partner · Markhoff & Mittman, P.C. [Call 866-205-2415](tel:18662052415) [Schedule with Brian](/contact-us/) - Admitted in New York - 30+ years in practice - Attends Board hearings personally Brian has personally handled New York workers' compensation, SSDI, and personal-injury cases for over three decades. Your case is never handed off to a paralegal. [Full bio & credentials →](/our-team/brian-mittman/)
- ![Randy Jacobs, Esq.](https://thedisabilityguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/tdg-randy-jacobs.jpg) ## Randy Jacobs, Esq. Attorney · Markhoff & Mittman, P.C. [Call 866-205-2415](tel:18662052415) [Schedule with Randy](/contact-us/) - Admitted in New York and New Jersey - Pace University School of Law, J.D. - Litigates before the Workers' Compensation Board Randy has litigated every type of claim before the Workers' Compensation Board on behalf of hundreds of claimants. [Full bio & credentials →](/our-team/randy-jacobs/)
- ![Benai Lifshitz, Esq.](https://thedisabilityguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/tdg-benai-lifshitz.jpg) ## Benai Lifshitz, Esq. Attorney · Markhoff & Mittman, P.C. [Call 866-205-2415](tel:18662052415) [Schedule with Benai](/contact-us/) - Admitted in New York, 2008 - New York Law School, J.D. 2007 - With The Disability Guys since 2013 Benai has spent more than a decade fighting for injured workers before the Workers' Compensation Board and the New York State Employees' Retirement Board. [Full bio & credentials →](/our-team/benai-lifshitz/)
- ![Emily Grajales, Esq.](https://thedisabilityguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/tdg-emily-grajales.jpg) ## Emily Grajales, Esq. Attorney · Markhoff & Mittman, P.C. [Call 866-205-2415](tel:18662052415) [Schedule with Emily](/contact-us/) - Admitted in New York, 2007 - 20 years in practice - Fluent in Spanish Emily has spent two decades on New York workers' compensation and Social Security Disability matters, including service as an Agency Attorney and Hearing Officer for NYC Transit and the MTA. [Full bio & credentials →](/our-team/emily-grajales/)
- ![Lauren Jurgens, Esq.](https://thedisabilityguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/09/tdg-lauren-jurgens.jpg) ## Lauren Jurgens, Esq. Attorney · Markhoff & Mittman, P.C. [Call 866-205-2415](tel:18662052415) [Schedule with Lauren](/contact-us/) - Admitted in New York, 2023 - Albany Law School, J.D. 2022 - Handles Third Department appeals Lauren represents injured workers in Workers' Compensation matters and handles appeals before the Appellate Division, Third Department. [Full bio & credentials →](/our-team/lauren-jurgens/)

## Need a long-term disability lawyer?

Free consultation. No fee unless we win. English or Spanish. Day or night.

[Call 866-205-2415](tel:18662052415) [Schedule a Free Consultation](/contact-us/)            ![The Disability Guys logo](https://thedisabilityguys.com/wp-content/uploads/2026/07/the-disability-guys-logo-horizontal.png)

**Markhoff & Mittman, P.C.**
Helping working New Yorkers for more than 93 years. The Unexpected Legal Experience.™

#### Practice Areas

- [Workers’ Compensation](/workers-compensation/)
- [Social Security Disability](/social-security-disability/)
- [Long-Term Disability](/long-term-disability/)
- [Personal Injury](/personal-injury-lawyers-in-new-york/)
- [Workers’ Rights](/workers-rights/)

#### Offices

- [White Plains (HQ)](/locations/white-plains/)
- [Yonkers](/locations/yonkers/)
- [Manhattan](/locations/manhattan/)
- [Brooklyn](/locations/brooklyn/)
- [Newburgh](/locations/newburgh/)
- [Goshen](/locations/goshen/)
- [Poughkeepsie](/locations/poughkeepsie/)

#### Firm

- [Why TDG](/why-tdg/)
- [Our Team](/our-team/)
- [Insights](/insights/)
- [Blog](/blog/)
- [For Partners](/for-partners/)
- [Contact Us](/contact-us/)
- [Español](/es/)
- [Accessibility Statement](/accessibility/)

© 2026 Markhoff & Mittman, P.C. d/b/a The Disability Guys. Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The content of this site is for general informational purposes only and is not legal advice. Use of this site does not create an attorney-client relationship. [Privacy](/privacy/) · [Terms](/terms/) · [Accessibility](/accessibility/)

---

Source: https://thedisabilityguys.com/long-term-disability/erisa-federal-court/
